Emmy Squared Pizza: Park Slope, Brooklyn

My partner and I opted for an all-vegan* build-your-own pizza (banana peppers, red onion, hot honey, and dairy-free cheese), and it was really, really good! Neither of us had ever had Detroit-style pizza before, and there weren’t any reviews written just yet about the vegan options that we had seen, so we went in with fairly low expectations. We were both definitely pleasantly surprised. The bread/crust and cheese both were super tasty! We weren’t starving, so the regular size ended up being perfect, but I would recommend for two people with a big appetite to go for the large. Drinks a little on the pricy side (11 bucks for a seltzer, 15 bucks for an IPA), but I do remember seeing a sign outside about happy hour specials, so maybe something to look out for in the future. Friendly staff and good vibes, great location… Gitton in ‘ere.(*Note: make sure you clearly communicate any dietary restrictions or preferences as the traditional dough is not vegan.)

Emmy’s is my favorite place to get a delicious Detroit-style pie. I’ve tried a few different pies from here, ‘the Big Ang’, ‘MVP’, and ‘VIP’ are among the ones that I’ve ordered. The VIP is not much different than the MVP; it just has pepperoni and Calabrian chilies in addition to the other MVP toppings. But for some reason, the MVP seems richer with the sauces. I’m also not a fan of the Calabrian chilies on the VIP, so I normally just order the MVP and just add pepperoni as a topping.After my last visit, I’ll be adding half grilled chicken and half pepperoni as my toppings to the MVP. I had been dreaming of the MVP pie and went there specifically for it, so after some SERIOUS deliberation, I decided to go with my favorite and order the regular sized MVP again.Overall I definitely recommend Emmy’s Squared, especially this location it’s not as busy as the ones in Manhattan. I personally think that it’s bigger to visit Emmy’s at Brooklyn location, if you can.

We ordered delivery and it is crazy to me how this place doesn’t have HIGHER RATINGS. SO GOOD.Very fresh produce used and authentic flavors.The Caesar salad was underwhelming in the box, but SO FRESH and flavorful with the dressing as you can taste the anchovies, which we love.We had the Colony pizza and Good Pauline pizza, both DELICIOUS. The crust was crunchy around the edges with golden cheese adding to the crunch, but paired with a beautifully balanced softer springy dough the more of the slice you eat.Will keep raving about this place to anyone who will listen. Will be flying back for this 100%1-2 slices would feed a small appetite person, a larger appetite I’d suggest 3-4 slices.

This spot pleasantly surprised me! The pizza was delicious: ordered the Hawaiian and a custom one and both were perfect. I do think one would have sufficed for myself and my husband, since we were just popping in for a casual lunch but we were happy for the take home leftovers!

The food was really good. Ordered the Brussel sprout salad, which was a great medley of bitter and tart flavors, also nice and saucy. The Pizza was really good. Gotta say as a New Yorker, I appreciate the cheesiness of a Detroit slice. Would definitely come back, the staff is great as well.

Amazing dog friendly staff but wait there’s more! Everything and I mean everything was delicious. The meatballs were ungodly good. The burger was cooked to perfection. The drinks were a smash. The apple pie oh my goodness it was heavenly. It was so good I came again on a four day trip to see if I had overhyped it. Nope the 2nd was amazing as well.

Such a cute and family friendly atmosphere. The manager Kyle was a delight and the neighborhood has loads of cute shops to pop into. Managed my dietary needs with ease and added protein to the Brussels sprouts and squash. I’ll have to get pizza next time.

This is my absolute favorite restaurant in Brooklyn, New York. The food is AMAZING and the PIZZA IS COOKED TO PERFECTION! Our Server Ivan went above and beyond to give efficient, happy and polite service. Our table food server Anthony had the best smile and was super polite! These two are best team and make this restaurant run smoothly!! side note, The menu is mainly pizza and don’t forget to get a salad and some wine! The restaurant is “kid friendly” with a children’s menu. If you download the restaurant app you can get 5 dollars off the next meal purchase. Just want to say that we Can’t wait to return and would definitely recommend to anyone else looking for somewhere to eat in and take in the best food in Brooklyn! Staff and management give one million stars service! Thanks so much we appreciate your restaurant and hospitality! Looking forward to coming back soon!